top of page

Dialogue – Differentiated Consensus - Qualified Dissent

Developing a transversal social ethics

Luisa Sello
Luisa Sello

In September 2014, Pope Francis in a private audience proposed a transversal  dialogue to two well-known Marxists, and a Catholic. This gave rise to the DIALOP initiative, which set itself the goal of developing a transversal social ethics.

The partners want to define exactly what they have in common and what their differences are. All in an atmosphere of openness, mutual respect and interest, against the background of a fundamental desire for consensus. Consensus means agreement, unanimity, approval; it is opposed to dissent, opposition and conflict; it is different from compromise or majority rule.


When it comes to consensus or dissent, initially there are different points of view or starting conditions that one wants to align to a certain extent through dialogue, which for DIALOP has two targets: differentiated consensus and qualified dissent.



Differentiated consent

The partners agree on a clearly formulated main statement, but there remain differences, expressed at a lower level, that do not conflict with the main state­ment. These legitimate secondary differences may concern starting points, approaches, motivations and justifications, linguistic expressions or differ­­rences in the manner of implementation. They are not perceived as a nuisance, but as an enrichment. One no longer looks at the world only through one's own window, but also through that of the other, thus finding a common horizon.


It is important that the differentiated consensus is not misunderstood as a compromise or locked into a bogus consensus. To avoid this danger and remain consistent in the long run, it must go, perhaps repeatedly, through some sort of dissent process.



Qualified dissent

Qualified dissent is said to exist when the difference in positions is too great to speak of a true consensus. At the same time, both positions are based on well-founded arguments, or verifiable facts and evidence.


Qualified dissent means that we know and understand each other's position and motives down to the ground, but do not share them (at least in part) and are aware of the distance between our positions (e.g. in the field of bioethics and abortion). But dialogue does not stop there.


Qualified dissent is not simply a transitional phase on the way to differentiated consensus. It is indispensable for issues where consensus seems unattainable from the current perspective, but which must not exclude from joint action (indeed, one can act together for peace).


Qualified dissent aims to distinguish between differences that can perhaps be resolved and those that cannot be resolved, at least for the time being, to bring those that can be resolved to a consensus.


Download the article ‘Towards a “Differentiated Consensus” by clicking on the button below

 

bottom of page